Can You Mix Tire Brands, Models, or Sizes on the Same Vehicle?

Can You Mix Tire Brands, Models, or Sizes on the Same Vehicle?

If you’ve ever had one tire ruined by a nail, pothole, or sidewall damage, you’ve probably wondered: Can I just replace one tire—even if it’s not the exact same model?

Here’s the simple, practical rule for most daily-driven vehicles:

• Replacing one tire with a different model is not recommended.
• If you can’t match the exact tire you already have, the safer approach is usually replacing at least two tires (both tires on the same axle).
• If you drive AWD/4WD, mismatched tires can cause handling issues and drivetrain stress—so you’ll want to follow your owner’s manual closely.

This guide explains what’s “technically possible” vs. what’s actually smart for safety, predictable handling, and long-term reliability.

---

Why Mixing Tires Can Be a Problem (Even If the Size Looks the Same)

Even when two tires share the same printed size (like 265/70R17), they can still behave very differently because of:

• Tread design (highway vs all-terrain vs winter-style patterns)
• Rubber compound (wet grip, cold grip, braking feel)
• Construction and stiffness (sidewall flex, steering response)
• True rolling diameter (can vary by model and changes as tread wears)

That mismatch can lead to inconsistent traction, strange steering feel, uneven braking, and stability control acting up—especially in rain or snow.

The Safest “Mixing” Rule (Easy to Remember)

Best → Better → Not recommended

1. Best: Replace all four tires with the same model (especially AWD/4WD).
2. Better: Replace two tires on the same axle, matched left-to-right.
3. Not recommended: Replace one tire with a different model (even if the size matches).

Can You Mix Tire Brands or Models?

Mixing brands/models front-to-rear

If you absolutely must mix, the “least risky” way is often front tires match each other and rear tires match each other.

That still isn’t ideal, but it’s usually more predictable than having different tires on the same axle.

Mixing brands/models left-to-right on the same axle

Avoid this. It’s one of the quickest ways to create:

• pulling or wandering
• inconsistent braking feel
• uneven traction in wet conditions
• odd behavior from traction control/ABS

If you’re replacing fewer than four, the baseline standard is:
✅ Match the two tires on the same axle.

Can You Replace Just One Tire?

Our practical stance: only if it’s an exact match

If you’re replacing one tire, it should match what’s on the vehicle as closely as possible:

• Same brand + model
• Same size
• Same load index
• Same speed rating

Even then, tread depth matters. A brand-new tire paired with a much more worn tire can create handling differences and (on AWD/4WD) drivetrain concerns.

If you can’t match the tire exactly…

Plan to replace at least two tires on the same axle. That gives you balanced handling left-to-right and avoids the “one grippy tire / one not-so-grippy tire” problem.

Where Should the Two New Tires Go: Front or Rear?

A lot of people assume the new tires should go on the drive axle, but most safety-focused guidance points to a different priority:

When replacing two tires, putting the newer pair on the rear helps stability, especially in wet conditions.
That reduces the chance of the rear losing traction first (which is harder for most drivers to correct).

What About AWD/4WD Vehicles?

This is where “just one tire” becomes a much bigger deal.

On AWD/4WD, tires that don’t match closely in overall diameter can make the system work harder than it should. That’s why many manufacturers specify a maximum allowable difference in tread depth or circumference.

If you drive AWD/4WD:

• Follow your owner’s manual recommendations first.
• If one tire is damaged and the others are worn down, the safest solution is often replacing all four (or otherwise ensuring tread depth/diameter is matched closely).

Can You Mix Tire Sizes?

In most cases: no, unless the vehicle is designed for it.

When different sizes can be OK

• Your vehicle came from the factory with a staggered setup (different front vs rear size), and you’re keeping that exact setup.

When different sizes are not OK

• Different sizes left-to-right on the same axle
• “Close enough” sizing guesses (especially on AWD/4WD)
• Any change that affects load rating, clearance, or overall diameter

Even small size changes can impact speedometer readings and traction/stability systems.

Need Help Matching What You Already Have?

If you’re trying to replace one tire and you’re not sure what matches your current setup, we can help you confirm the right size and specs so your vehicle stays safe and predictable.

Call 320-247-6160 for expert help. All orders ship free and financing is available at checkout.

SHOP TIRES NOW